Top Five Underrated Scotch Whiskies You Should Try
Great Hidden Gem Whiskies
Great Hidden Gem Whiskies
Us, whisky enthusiasts often find themselves talking about the same bottles. Arran, Springbank, Kilkerran and Signatory Vintage are all brilliant, but there is a whole world of whisky out there that deserves a little more attention.
So, I picked out five underrated whiskies that I think are well worth discovering. From coastal single malts and interesting cask finishes to a surprisingly good budget blend. Hopefully there is something here for all drinkers on their journey
Often overshadowed by the peated Ledaig, Tobermory 12 is a brilliant single malt that deserves to be talked about more.
Made on the Isle of Mull, Tobermory has a history stretching back over two centuries. This 12 year old release is bottled at 46.3% ABV, with natural colour and no chill filtration. Those are impressive specifications, especially when you consider the price.
The nose brings plenty of fresh oranges and apples, alongside honey biscuits and freshly cut hay. On the palate, it is creamy, warming and gently coastal, with orchard fruits and lovely floral notes.
It is an easy whisky to enjoy, but there is enough character to keep more experienced drinkers interested too.
At around £40 in the UK, it is already good value. Pick it up on offer and it becomes an absolute bargain. Fans of Arran 10, Glencadam or lighter, fruitier Highland whiskies should definitely give this one a try.
Ardnamurchan is already well regarded among whisky enthusiasts, but its Midgie Batch 2 release deserves more attention.
This batch two is released in 2025, a non age statement single malt bottled at 48% ABV, natural colour and no chill filtration. It combines peated and unpeated spirit, with a cask recipe of 50% bourbon, 48% Port Barriques and 2% sherry casks.
For me, this is one of the most enjoyable Ardnamurchan releases so far. Compared with the previous batch, it has a much fruitier and jammy character, with more depth and sweetness.
Strawberry jam tarts, dark chocolate, caramelised pineapple and tropical fruits, balanced by a little coastal saltiness and a gentle wisp of smoke.
It sits in an interesting place for fans of Ledaig Rioja Sinclair Series or Talisker Port Ruighe, with some of the earthy character you might recognise from Benromach Peat Smoke.
With a UK retail price around £50, it is worth looking for offers. I picked mine up for just under £40, which is well worth it.
Part of the Batch 2 collection, this is a six year old single malt Scotch bottled at a powerful 58% ABV.
It starts its maturation in first fill bourbon casks before spending just over three months finishing in French Cognac casks.
The nose is rich and slightly musty, with pears in syrup, apple strudel and honey alongside a gentle hint of smoke.
On the palate, it feels surprisingly mature for its age. There are rounded caramel and leathery notes, with a brighter fruity finish that lifts everything. The smoke is subtle, sometimes almost easy to mistake for oak spice.
Cognac casks can be a little hit and miss, but this combination works particularly well. It is a different take on peated whisky and one of my favourite releases from Glasgow 1770. It is listed at £59 on the distillery website at the moment.
Not just highlighting a single overlooked bottle, I think the Torabhaig distillery as a whole deserves more attention.
Based on the Isle of Skye, Torabhaig is a relatively young distillery with the unavoidable challenge of following in the footsteps of Talisker. However, I think it is producing some very interesting whisky in its own right. Allt Gleann is bottled at 46% ABV, with natural colour and no chill filtration. The distillery also provides plenty of detail about its production, including information about the malt, yeast, maturation and phenol levels.
The whisky uses approximately 80% first fill bourbon casks and 20% refill bourbon casks, allowing the spirit character to shine.
On the nose, expect fresh lemons, bananas and a noticeable smoky character. The palate brings salt, smoke, burnt seaweed, apples, biscuits and a good hit of ground pepper.
There are obvious comparisons with Talisker, but I can also see similarities with salty Ledaig, peated Bunnahabhain and even Kilchoman’s Machir Bay.
At around £40 in the UK, it offers plenty to explore and am keen to try more from Torabhaig and see how the distillery develops.
This might be the most controversial pick on the list but I stand by it.
Naked Malt is a blended Scotch whisky, and I feel it is one of the better “cheap” bottles you can pick up.
At under £22 in some shops it is an approachable sherried whisky that is not particularly complex or heavy. but that is part of the appeal.
I have introduced this bottle to several people who do not normally drink Scotch, and it always seems to go down well.
There were plenty of other contenders that nearly made the list. Fettercairn Warehouse 2, Bunnahabhain Stiùireadair, Lochlea Our Barley, Symington’s 10 and almost every Loch Lomond.
Discover more by watching the full video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnruhhNcRM8